Mai 2007
Abstract
Background : France is in Europe, the country in which the mortality due to potentially preventable causes is the highest. At the same time, French doctors receive no incentives to undertake prevention activities. This article examined the general practitioners’ (GPs) determinants (characteristics, patient list and contextual factors) of cardiovascular prevention and vaccination carried out by GPs in their offices.
Methods : Data were collected from 105,726 patients followed by 86 GPs (observational study). A multilevel analysis with two levels: GP and patient (HLM®) was performed.
Results : A high between-GP variability of the prevention activity is underlined in both domains. After controlling for patient characteristics, we observed a positive effect of the GP's workload (ORa=1.03) and of an elderly GP's patient list (ORa=1.04) on cardiovascular prevention, a positive effect of a patient list with a high level of health care consumption on vaccination activity (ORa=1.04). The significant influence of contextual factors is ever more demonstrative: the ORa is 1.3 times lower in cardiovascular prevention and 1.6 in vaccination when the density of GPs in the local community of the doctor's practice grows of one-point (1/1000); the ORa is two times lower in both cardiovascular prevention and vaccination for GPs having an urban practice.
Conclusion : These results emphasize the need for taking into account contextual factors to implement prevention policies in primary care. But further studies of this type should be conducted by taking other variables into account in order to improve the proportion of variance explained in our models.
Background : France is in Europe, the country in which the mortality due to potentially preventable causes is the highest. At the same time, French doctors receive no incentives to undertake prevention activities. This article examined the general practitioners’ (GPs) determinants (characteristics, patient list and contextual factors) of cardiovascular prevention and vaccination carried out by GPs in their offices.
Methods : Data were collected from 105,726 patients followed by 86 GPs (observational study). A multilevel analysis with two levels: GP and patient (HLM®) was performed.
Results : A high between-GP variability of the prevention activity is underlined in both domains. After controlling for patient characteristics, we observed a positive effect of the GP's workload (ORa=1.03) and of an elderly GP's patient list (ORa=1.04) on cardiovascular prevention, a positive effect of a patient list with a high level of health care consumption on vaccination activity (ORa=1.04). The significant influence of contextual factors is ever more demonstrative: the ORa is 1.3 times lower in cardiovascular prevention and 1.6 in vaccination when the density of GPs in the local community of the doctor's practice grows of one-point (1/1000); the ORa is two times lower in both cardiovascular prevention and vaccination for GPs having an urban practice.
Conclusion : These results emphasize the need for taking into account contextual factors to implement prevention policies in primary care. But further studies of this type should be conducted by taking other variables into account in order to improve the proportion of variance explained in our models.
Mots clés : General practitioners, Preventive services, Primary care, Multilevel analysis, Cardiovascular prevention, Vaccination